Judicial Responses to Religious Freedom: A Case Analysis
Abstract
This study examines a cross section of case law in order to assess how far Sri Lanka’s judiciary has been willing to go to uphold the freedom of religion. The report is presented in three parts. The first part sets out the legal framework applicable to religious freedom in Sri Lanka. The second analyses how courts have interpreted and applied this legal framework in the context of three dimensions, namely (1) the right to adopt and hold a religious belief (2) the right to manifest a religious belief (3) the right to non-discrimination on the basis of religion. The final part classifies the analysed cases on perceptual maps to identify key trends in the judicial protection of the freedom of religion in Sri Lanka. The Sri Lankan case law has displayed a conservative trend in terms of the protection and promotion of religious rights of minority religious communities. This trend may be attributed to at least three key factors. First, the Supreme Court has a tendency to use a procedural approach when determining outcomes that protect minority religious rights. Second, the Supreme Court has been reluctant to apply a meaningful proportionality test when determining outcomes. Last, the lower courts have demonstrated a reluctance to mediate community level tensions in order to protect minority religious communities.
Note
Description
35p. This report is produced by Verite Research based on information provided by the National Christian Evangelical Alliance of Sri Lanka (NCEASL). It was prepared by Sabrina Esufally, with the research support of Sanjit Dias.
Collections
- Research Reports [42]
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Prejudice and Patronage: An Analysis of Incidents of Violence against Christians, Muslims, Hindus in Sri Lanka (September 2019 – September 2020)
Nicolle, Stephanie; Media Team, Verité Research (Colombo: Verité Research, 2021)This study offers insights in key trends and drivers of religious violence from September 2019 to September 2020. A total of 63 incidents of violence against Christians as well as episodes of discrimination against Muslims ...